Why Are Mortgages So Expensive in Canada?

Finance

March 30, 2025

Canadian homebuyers are getting crushed right now. Mortgage costs have gone through the roof, and many folks wonder if they'll ever own a home. Trust me, I get it. Your mortgage eats up way more of your paycheck than you ever expected. You're not alone in feeling the squeeze. Here's the deal: No single villain is making Canadian mortgages so pricey. It's more like a bunch of factors all piling on at once. Some you can control, most you can't. However, knowing the driving costs can help you make smarter moves with your home financing.

Strong Economic Growth Means More Demand for Money

Why Are Mortgages So Expensive in Canada?

The idea needs some initial thought to be understood. Hot economic conditions in Canada result in higher mortgage costs. Life during prosperous times should be less challenging, according to common sense. Not quite.

Standing economic strength results in higher employment numbers with increased payment amounts. Awesome! The growing loan money becomes the target of increased competition from borrowers. The available funds that banks distribute for loans are limited. Rates rise when demand reaches high levels, according to basic economic principles.

The situation became evident when Vancouver experienced it several years ago. My consulting work coincided with the influx of technology companies into the city, which transformed it into a sea of high-paying job opportunities. According to my colleague, TD Bank experienced a surge in mortgage applications, which rose to double the previous numbers. Banks would not provide attractive deals because high market demand existed. The banks did not require competition since they had enough business to handle.

When homebuyers from different income levels enter the housing market, prices surge. Higher prices mean bigger loans, which force borrowers to make more significant payments regardless of interest rates staying unchanged. It's like getting punched twice.

The Global Economy Matters

Your Canadian mortgage operates through an unusual connection with the financial events in Tokyo and London. Canadian mortgage rates do not exist independently of international market changes.

The Federal Reserve rate increases in the United States typically cause Canadian interest rates to move in the same direction. The rising mortgage rates occur against our will since we lack other options. The purchase of Canadian mortgage securities and government bonds goes to international investors. Global investors pull out their investments when interest rates increase worldwide unless Canadian rates match their pace. The movement of their funds to other markets damages our entire economic system.

Foreign investors have created extreme market conditions throughout Vancouver and Toronto. The market prices rise dramatically because foreign investors purchase properties as if they were collecting Pokemon cards. Higher prices equal bigger mortgages and more painful monthly payments.

Canada appears to be a risk-free investment during global economic instability. Our country's real estate market is known for its stability. During times of uncertainty, investors choose to deposit their funds in Canada, making it favorable for themselves but creating an unfavorable situation for first-time home buyers.

The Bank of Canada Influences Interest Rates

The Bank of Canada is the culprit behind your mortgage pain. The effects ripple through the entire housing market when they tweak their overnight rate. Commercial banks build their prime rates on this foundation, directly impacting variable mortgage costs.

Their job isn't making homes affordable - it's fighting inflation. When prices climb too fast across the economy, they crank rates to cool things down. Your mortgage is just collateral damage in that fight.

Fixed-rate mortgages dance to a slightly different tune. They're tied to bond yields, not the Bank of Canada's rate. However, these bonds still react to the Bank's policies and economic forecasts. When the Bank hints at future rate hikes, bond yields climb, and fixed mortgage rates follow.

Those 0.25% increases might sound tiny, but they pack a punch. Each quarter-point bump adds roughly $70 monthly on a $500,000 mortgage. The Bank has hiked rates multiple times recently, and homeowners feel every single one in their bank accounts.

Repayment or Credit Risk

Borrowers who fail to pay their debts cause intense anxiety among lenders. Repayment or credit risk is a significant factor determining the mortgage cost you will pay.

The score you have demonstrates your financial report to lenders. Lenders obsess over it. A credit score lower than 680 will increase mortgage interest rates between 1% and 2%. Your mortgage repayment costs will total tens of thousands because of the increased interest rates.

Do you have inconsistent income? You'll pay for it. The lack of stable income forces freelancers, self-employed people, and contractors to pay higher mortgage rates. Lenders love boring, predictable paychecks. Monthly income instability triggers warning signals in the eyes of lenders.

The money you pay upfront for your home purchase proves more significant than most homeowners understand. Mortgage insurance becomes necessary when you pay less than 20% of the purchase price. The insurance premium goes directly to the lender and not to you, even though it safeguards their investment if you default on your payments. Yep, that's all on you. The insurance premiums become part of your total mortgage expenses.

Previous market failures made Canadian lenders cautious about their lending practices. The lending standards have become stricter because they focus on doubtful applicants. The lending industry uses heightened precautions to increase mortgage costs for all borrowers.

Interest Rate Risk

Selecting a five-year fixed-rate mortgage requires your lender to make a financial bet. The rates could potentially increase by 3% within that period, leaving the lender with minimal income compared to existing market rates. The lenders need to protect themselves from interest rate risk, so they raise the cost of mortgage loans.

The length of the financing period increases the potential risks that lenders face. The risk involved in fixed rates for five years leads to higher rates than variable rates. You're paying for certainty.

Predicting interest rate movements requires extensive teams of analysts working in banks. These predictions about future rates become part of the current mortgage interest rates. The expectation that interest rates will increase causes lenders to include those anticipated higher rates within current fixed-rate pricing.

Because of this phenomenon, mortgage rates tend to behave independently from Bank of Canada overnight rates. The simple markup process does not apply to how lenders determine their rates. Future rate changes guide their pricing strategy.

Prepayment Risk

Why Are Mortgages So Expensive in Canada?

Interest payments generate the bulk of banking institutions' profits year after year. When you pay off your mortgage early, the bank loses the potential revenue stream from future interest payments. The prepayment risk factor significantly influences how lenders determine their mortgage pricing.

Householders refinance their homes through rate reductions or by selling their properties. The bank's anticipated profits experience premature termination when clients make these transactions. Lenders incorporate the risk into their mortgage pricing structure. Your financial expertise requires banks to charge you an additional fee as insurance.

Most Canadian mortgages let you make some extra payments each year without penalties. Go beyond those limits, though, and you'll get slapped with prepayment charges. These can be brutal, especially with fixed-rate mortgages. They're designed to recover what the lender would have earned if you'd stuck to the original payment schedule.

Variable-rate mortgages typically have softer prepayment penalties, which is one reason their rates often undercut fixed rates. The lender faces less prepayment risk with variable products.

Always read the fine print on prepayment terms. The lowest rate isn't automatically the best deal if it comes with harsh penalties for early payoff.

Conclusion

Canadian mortgages cost an arm and a leg because of a perfect storm of factors. Economic growth cranks up demand and pushes rates higher—global economic trends blow back on our local market. The Bank of Canada fights inflation at the expense of your mortgage payment. Lenders price in various risks: your credit risk, interest rate movements, and the chance you'll pay early.

These factors hit every borrower differently. Your unique financial situation determines precisely how bad your mortgage pain will be. Shopping around is critical. Different lenders see risk differently, which leads to wildly varying rates.

Despite the brutal market conditions, homeownership remains within reach for many Canadians. Understanding what drives mortgage costs helps you navigate the system more effectively. Boost your credit score and save for a more significant down payment - these moves can dramatically reduce what you'll pay.

The mortgage landscape keeps shifting, but these fundamental drivers aren't going anywhere. With this knowledge, you can approach your home financing with wide-open eyes. You can't change the broad economic tides, but you can position yourself to get the best possible deal in this challenging market.

Also Read: How to Sell Your Amazon Gift Cards for Cash or Crypto

Frequently Asked Questions

Find quick answers to common questions about this topic

Our mortgages work differently than American ones. We typically use shorter terms with renewals every few years. Our regulatory system, risk assessment, and housing policies all push our rates higher than what Americans pay.

Bad credit hammers your rate. Score below 680, and you'll pay 0.5-1% more interest. That's roughly $150-300 extra monthly on a $500,000 mortgage.

Depends how much uncertainty you can stomach. Variable rates start lower but can bounce around. Fixed rates cost more initially but give peace of mind. Your financial stability should guide this choice.

Put down at least 5% for homes under $500K. For homes between $500K and $1M, it's 5% on the first $500K and 10% on the rest. Homes over $1M require 20% down, no exceptions.

About the author

Lucas Bennet

Lucas Bennet

Contributor

...

View articles