In Massachusetts, the terms “stay away order” and “restraining order” are often used interchangeably, but they serve distinct legal purposes and have nuanced differences. Understanding these differences is crucial for both those seeking protection and those who may be subject to such orders. This article explores the intricacies of stay away orders and restraining orders in Massachusetts, providing a comprehensive guide that goes beyond the surface-level information typically found online.
The Difference Between Stay Away Order vs Restraining Order
Massachusetts Appeals Court has provided critical clarification on what constitutes a “stay away” order within the context of restraining orders. This clarification is pivotal for both petitioners and respondents, as it delineates the boundaries of legally enforceable behavior.
Case Study: Commonwealth v. Gentleman
One landmark case, Commonwealth v. Gentleman, illustrated the complexities involved. The court ruled that a “stay away” order not only prohibits physical proximity but can also extend to indirect forms of contact such as phone calls, emails, and even social media interactions. This ruling underscores the importance for respondents to fully understand all terms of their orders to avoid unintentional violations.
How Does A Restraining Order Work?
A restraining order, also known as a protective order, is a legal injunction issued by a court to prevent an individual from engaging in specific behaviors, typically to protect another person from harm or harassment. In Massachusetts, these orders are crucial tools for safeguarding individuals from domestic violence, stalking, and other forms of abuse.
The Process of Obtaining a Restraining Order
- Filing a Complaint: The process begins with the petitioner filing a complaint at a courthouse. This complaint outlines the reasons for seeking the order and any incidents of abuse or harassment.
- Temporary Order: The court may issue a temporary restraining order (TRO) immediately if it finds sufficient evidence of immediate danger. This order typically lasts up to 10 days until the full hearing.
- Hearing: A full court hearing is scheduled where both parties can present evidence and testimony. The judge then decides whether to issue a more permanent order, which can last up to one year and be renewed.
Enforcement and Compliance
Once issued, a restraining order is enforceable by law enforcement. Violating any terms of the order can result in criminal charges, including fines and imprisonment.
Who Can A Restraining Order Be Obtained Against?
In Massachusetts, restraining orders can be issued against a variety of individuals, not limited to domestic partners or family members.
Eligible Relationships
- Family Members: This includes spouses, former spouses, relatives by blood or marriage, and those who have a child in common.
- Household Members: Individuals who currently reside or have resided together.
- Dating Relationships: Those who are or have been in a substantive dating relationship, assessed by the court based on the duration, frequency, and type of interaction.
Who Can Get a Restraining Order (209A Order) in Massachusetts?
Under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 209A, commonly known as a 209A Order, individuals can seek protection if they are experiencing abuse. Abuse is defined broadly and includes:
- Attempting or causing physical harm.
- Placing another in fear of imminent serious physical harm.
- Causing another to engage involuntarily in sexual relations by force, threat, or duress.
Criteria for Petitioners
To qualify for a 209A Order, the petitioner must demonstrate:
- Evidence of Abuse: This can include police reports, medical records, witness statements, and any other relevant documentation.
- Relationship with the Respondent: The petitioner must prove that their relationship with the respondent fits one of the eligible categories mentioned above.
What Does a Massachusetts Restraining Order Do?
A Massachusetts restraining order can encompass a variety of provisions designed to protect the petitioner from further harm.
Common Provisions
- No Contact Orders: Prohibiting any form of contact, including phone calls, texts, emails, and social media interactions.
- Stay Away Orders: Mandating that the respondent stays a certain distance away from the petitioner’s home, workplace, or other specified locations.
- Custody and Support Orders: Temporarily addressing issues of child custody, visitation, and support if applicable.
- Personal Property: Directing the respondent to surrender firearms and other dangerous weapons to the authorities.
Enforcement Mechanisms
Law enforcement agencies are tasked with enforcing these provisions. Immediate arrest can occur if the respondent is found violating any terms of the order.
Types of Restraining Orders
In Massachusetts, several types of restraining orders can be issued based on the specifics of the case and the needs of the petitioner.
1. Abuse Prevention Orders (209A Orders)
These are the most common and are specifically designed to protect individuals from domestic violence. They include provisions for no contact, stay away, and other protective measures.
2. Harassment Prevention Orders (Chapter 258E Orders)
These orders are designed to protect individuals from harassment, stalking, and other forms of severe intimidation from parties with whom they do not have a domestic relationship. This can include neighbors, co-workers, or strangers.
3. Criminal Restraining Orders
Issued as part of criminal proceedings, these orders typically accompany charges of assault, harassment, or other criminal behavior. They are used to protect victims or witnesses from further harm or intimidation by the defendant.
What Proof Do You Need to Get a Restraining Order?
Obtaining a restraining order in Massachusetts requires the petitioner to provide sufficient evidence that justifies the need for protection.
Types of Evidence
- Direct Evidence: This includes tangible proof such as photographs of injuries, damaged property, medical records, and police reports.
- Testimonial Evidence: The petitioner’s testimony, along with statements from witnesses who have observed the abuse or harassment.
- Documentary Evidence: Text messages, emails, social media posts, and other written communications that indicate threats or abusive behavior.
Burden of Proof
While the burden of proof is on the petitioner, the standard in civil proceedings for restraining orders is typically “preponderance of the evidence,” which is a lower threshold than the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard used in criminal cases.
Restraining Order Consequences
The issuance of a restraining order carries significant consequences for the respondent, affecting various aspects of their life.
Legal Consequences
- Criminal Record: Violating a restraining order can lead to criminal charges, resulting in a permanent criminal record.
- Firearm Restrictions: Respondents are typically required to surrender any firearms and are prohibited from purchasing new ones.
Personal and Professional Impact
- Employment: A restraining order can affect current and future employment opportunities, particularly in fields requiring background checks.
- Reputation: The stigma associated with a restraining order can impact personal relationships and social standing.
- Custody and Visitation: If children are involved, a restraining order can influence custody and visitation arrangements.
What Happens If I Violate a Restraining Order?
Violating a restraining order in Massachusetts is a serious offense with immediate and long-term repercussions.
Immediate Consequences
- Arrest: Law enforcement is authorized to arrest the respondent without a warrant if there is probable cause to believe the order has been violated.
- Criminal Charges: The respondent may face criminal charges, which can result in fines, probation, or imprisonment.
Long-term Consequences
- Extended Orders: The court may extend the duration of the restraining order or impose additional restrictions.
- Additional Legal Issues: Repeated violations can lead to further legal actions, including potential civil lawsuits by the petitioner.
How is a Violation of a Restraining Order Proven?
Proving a violation of a restraining order requires the petitioner to demonstrate that the respondent knowingly and willfully disobeyed the terms of the order.
Evidence for Proving Violation
- Witness Testimony: Statements from individuals who witnessed the violation.
- Documentation: Any form of communication or evidence indicating the respondent’s actions, such as text messages, emails, or phone records.
- Law Enforcement Reports: Police records and incident reports documenting the violation.
Legal Proceedings
The burden of proof lies with the prosecution in criminal cases, requiring them to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the respondent violated the order. In civil contempt proceedings, the standard is typically a preponderance of the evidence.
Conclusion
Understanding the distinctions between a stay away order and a restraining order in Massachusetts is essential for anyone involved in such legal matters. Each type of order serves unique purposes and carries different implications for the petitioner and respondent. By comprehensively navigating the legal landscape, individuals can better protect themselves and ensure they are fully informed of their rights and responsibilities.
ALSO READ: The 10 Cheapest Law Schools in California
FAQs
A stay away order is a specific provision within a restraining order that mandates the respondent to maintain a certain distance from the petitioner. A restraining order, in contrast, encompasses a broader range of protective measures, including no contact orders and custody arrangements.
A restraining order can initially last up to one year but can be extended by the court upon review. Temporary restraining orders (TROs) typically last up to 10 days until a full court hearing takes place.
Yes, either party can request the court to modify or lift the restraining order. This usually requires a formal motion and a subsequent hearing where both parties can present their case.
It is crucial to comply with all terms of the order immediately and seek legal counsel to understand your rights and options. Failure to comply can result in serious legal consequences.
If you believe the restraining order is unjustified, you can present evidence and testimony at the court hearing to refute the claims. Legal representation can significantly enhance your defense.
